“As soon as you see a cloud coming up in the west, you say ‘It’s going to rain’, and it does. When the south wind blows, you say, ‘It’s going to get hot,’ and it does.” –Luke 12:54-55 (CEV)
When we were checking the Embera draft of Luke 12:54-55, we ran into some weather problems. In these verses Jesus is commenting on the typical weather patterns in Israel: a west wind from the Mediterranean Sea brings rain clouds and the south wind off the Sinai and Arabian deserts brings heat.
The weather patterns in Embera territory are the opposite: rain comes from the east and when it’s hot and dry, the winds come out of the north. To complicate the matter, Emberas don’t give directions using the four points of the compass. You can translate ‘east’ as “where the sun appears” and ‘west’ as “where the sun falls”, but there is nothing for ‘north’ or ’south’. People usually use directional words like upriver, downriver, in the headwaters, across the river, inland, beyond X, this side of Y, near Z, and so on.
In solving this translation problem we cannot alter the meaning. This means that in tailoring the translation for the Emberas we cannot have Jesus saying that the rain in Israel comes from the east or the hot wind comes from the north. However, we do not have to use the four points of the compass to describe the weather; it confuses the Emberas, anyway, because their weather is the opposite. Suddenly we got an idea. Instead of “where the sun falls” for ‘west’, we decided to use “on the side of the sea.” Since the Mediterranean is to the west of Israel, that is a legitimate way to translate ‘west’. For ’south’ in Embera we decided to try “on the side of the land”, which describes what is immediately south of Israel. It also implies the direction away from the sea.
The Embera working with us last week liked the solution. Here is what the Embera draft sounds like in English:
“When you see clouds on the side of the sea, you say ‘rain will come’. Just like this, the rain comes. When the wind blows from the side of the land, you say ‘it will be very hot’. Just like this it really happens.”